- Opening Hours: Mon - Sat 7:00am – 6:00pm
- Phone Number: (207) 922-7082
The two most popular residential roofing choices today are asphalt shingles and metal roofing. Both are excellent options, and both can serve Maine homeowners well when properly installed. The best choice for your home depends on your priorities, your budget, how long you plan to stay in the home, and what you value most in a roofing system. Here's an honest comparison.
Contact Allstate Roofing today for your free roof replacement estimate.
Same-Day Quotes
Repairs From $250
350+ Five Star Reviews
Licensed & Insured
Free Estimates
Serving Since 2015
Same-Day Quotes
Repairs From $250
350+ Five Star Reviews
Licensed & Insured
Free Estimates
Serving Since 2015
Same-Day Quotes
Repairs From $250
350+ Five Star Reviews
Licensed & Insured
Free Estimates
Serving Since 2015
Same-Day Quotes
Repairs From $250
350+ Five Star Reviews
Licensed & Insured
Free Estimates
Serving Since 2015
Upfront Installation Cost
Asphalt shingles are generally less expensive to install than metal roofing. The material cost difference can be significant, particularly when comparing entry-level asphalt shingles to premium standing seam metal systems. For homeowners with a limited budget or who plan to sell their home in the near term, asphalt shingles offer a quality roofing solution at a lower initial investment.
Long-Term Cost of Ownership
Over a 50-year period, the cost comparison shifts considerably. A metal roof may be installed once and last the full 50 years with minimal maintenance. Asphalt shingles may need to be replaced twice in that same period, meaning two full installation costs plus waste disposal, each time facing current labor and material pricing. When calculated per year of useful life, metal roofing frequently delivers better long-term value.
In Maine's Winters
Metal roofing has a meaningful advantage in Maine's winter climate. Its smooth surface sheds snow naturally, reducing the likelihood of ice dam formation. Metal doesn't absorb moisture, so freeze-thaw cycling causes no degradation. Metal roofing systems tested to Class 4 impact resistance withstand hail better than most asphalt shingles.
Asphalt shingles can perform well in Maine winters when installed with proper underlayment systems, ice-and-water shield, and adequate attic ventilation. However, they are more vulnerable to ice dam damage and show age more quickly under repeated freeze-thaw cycling than metal.
Wind and Hail Resistance
Standing seam metal roofing, with no exposed fasteners, provides excellent wind uplift resistance. Impact-resistant asphalt shingles offer improved hail resistance and carry Class 4 ratings comparable to metal, but standard three-tab and even many architectural shingles are more vulnerable to hail impact than metal panels.
Asphalt Shingle Appearance
Asphalt shingles are available in dozens of colors and profiles, including styles that mimic the appearance of wood shake or slate. They are familiar and blend easily with most residential architectural styles. Many homeowners find them the more traditional and expected choice.
Metal Roofing Aesthetics
Metal roofing has evolved dramatically in recent years. Standing seam provides a clean, modern look that is increasingly popular on contemporary and farmhouse-style homes. Metal shingles can replicate the appearance of wood shake, slate, and tile. For homeowners seeking a distinctive look or pursuing energy efficiency and modern design, metal offers compelling aesthetic options.
Metal roofing, particularly with light-colored or reflective finishes, reflects more solar radiation than most asphalt shingle options, reducing summer cooling loads. In Maine's climate where heating costs are the primary energy concern, the difference is less dramatic than in southern states, but reflective metal roofing can contribute meaningfully to year-round energy performance.
If you prioritize lowest upfront cost and a traditional appearance, asphalt shingles are an excellent choice that will serve you well for 25 to 30 years with proper maintenance. If you prioritize long-term value, minimal maintenance, exceptional weather resistance, and are planning to stay in your home for the foreseeable future, metal roofing deserves serious consideration.
for a free consultation. We install both systems and will give you an honest recommendation based on your specific home and goals.
