How to Choose Roofing Materials

Choosing the right roofing material is one of the most consequential decisions you'll make for your home. The material you select affects your roof's lifespan, your home's energy performance, its curb appeal, and your experience maintaining it for decades. At Allstate Roofing, we want every homeowner to make this decision with complete information. Here's a comprehensive guide to selecting the right roofing material for your home in Maine.

Claim Your Free
Roofing Quote Today!

  • Same-Day Quotes
  • Repairs From $250
  • 350+ Five Star Reviews
  • Licensed & Insured
  • Free Estimates
  • Serving Since 2015
  • Same-Day Quotes
  • Repairs From $250
  • 350+ Five Star Reviews
  • Licensed & Insured
  • Free Estimates
  • Serving Since 2015
  • Same-Day Quotes
  • Repairs From $250
  • 350+ Five Star Reviews
  • Licensed & Insured
  • Free Estimates
  • Serving Since 2015
  • Same-Day Quotes
  • Repairs From $250
  • 350+ Five Star Reviews
  • Licensed & Insured
  • Free Estimates
  • Serving Since 2015

Start With Your Climate

Maine's climate is the first filter to apply when evaluating roofing materials. Any material you choose should be able to handle heavy snow loads without sagging or failing, resist the freeze-thaw cycling that occurs repeatedly throughout winter, manage ice dam risks at the eaves, handle occasional high winds from nor'easters and coastal storms, and resist the moisture and biological growth that come with Maine's damp climate.

All major roofing materials can be made to work in Maine with proper installation, but some perform more naturally and require less maintenance in these conditions. Metal roofing excels at shedding snow and resisting moisture. Slate and tile handle temperature extremes and freeze-thaw cycling very well. Properly installed asphalt shingles with ice-and-water shield protection perform reliably through Maine winters.

Claim Your Free
Roofing Quote Today!

Evaluate Your Budget Honestly

Upfront Cost vs. Total Cost of Ownership

The most common mistake homeowners make when evaluating roofing materials is comparing only the upfront installation cost. A proper evaluation considers the cost per year of useful life. An asphalt shingle roof that costs $12,000 and lasts 25 years has an annual cost of $480. A metal roof that costs $22,000 and lasts 60 years has an annual cost of $367. Over the long term, the more expensive material may actually be the more economical choice.

Maintenance Costs

Some materials require significantly more ongoing maintenance than others. Wood shake roofing requires periodic cleaning, treatment, and individual piece replacement. Asphalt shingles require occasional repair. Metal, slate, and tile require minimal maintenance when properly installed. Factor maintenance costs into your total budget evaluation.

Consider Your Home's Structure

Roof Load Capacity

Heavy materials like natural slate and concrete tile require structural support that not every home is built to provide. Before selecting a heavy roofing material, a structural assessment should confirm that your home's framing can handle the added load. If reinforcement is needed, that cost should be factored into your budget evaluation.

Roof Pitch

Some materials are appropriate only for certain roof pitches. Most asphalt shingles require a minimum pitch of 2:12 to 4:12. Metal roofing can be used on very low slopes. Tile and slate typically require steeper pitches. Your roof's geometry will influence your material options.

Think About Aesthetics and Long-Term Satisfaction

Your roof is a major visual element of your home's exterior. The material and color you choose will affect your home's appearance for the life of the roof. Consider how the material complements your home's architectural style, how it will look as it ages, and whether you'll still be satisfied with it a decade from now.

Let Allstate Roofing Guide Your Decision

Choosing a roofing material is a big decision, and you don't have to make it alone. Allstate Roofing provides free consultations to help homeowners evaluate their options and select the material that best fits their home, climate, budget, and goals. Contact us today to start the conversation.